Ellinger Bell Secures Appellate Win for City of Springfield in Torch Electronics License Case10/31/2026
On October 27, 2026, the Missouri Court of Appeals, Western District, unanimously affirmed the City of Springfield's denial of a business license renewal to Torch Electronics, LLC, rejecting all four points Torch raised on appeal. Marc H. Ellinger and Stephanie S. Bell of Ellinger Bell represented the City of Springfield in Torch Electronics, LLC v. City of Springfield, Missouri, No. WD88364. Judge W. Douglas Thomson authored the opinion. Springfield enacted Section 78-10 of its City Code in February 2024, prohibiting any person from maintaining or offering for use an entertainment device that offers a monetary prize. Torch places coin-operated amusement machines that award vouchers redeemable for cash, an occupation requiring an annual city business license. The Director of Finance declined to renew that license under Section 70-51(a), which bars issuance when the Director has reason to believe the business will operate in violation of the Code. A hearing officer upheld the denial, and the Circuit Court of Cole County affirmed. The Court of Appeals held that the City made a licensing decision rather than an adjudication of an ordinance violation: no citation was issued, no penalty was imposed, and the hearing officer held no final authority over whether a violation occurred. The Court distinguished Yellow Freight Systems and City of Springfield v. Belt, instead following O'Brien v. Department of Public Safety, which recognizes that administrative licensing proceedings are distinct from criminal prosecution. The Court also rejected Torch's claim that Section 572.100, RSMo preempts the ordinance, because Section 78-10 expressly excludes gambling devices prohibited by state law and devices necessary for state-licensed gaming, and so reaches nothing covered by Chapter 572. The decision is significant for Missouri municipalities addressing cash-prize entertainment devices. It confirms that a city may act through its licensing authority without first obtaining a conviction in municipal court, and that an ordinance drafted to carve out conduct already governed by Chapter 572 can withstand a preemption challenge. Ellinger Bell represents municipalities, businesses, and organizations in gaming, local government, professional licensing, regulatory, and appellate matters. Comments are closed.
|
